‘There’s no magic money tree’: Alex Depledge on the Budget, startup lobbying and why she left the UK government

We have entered the era of the hard pivot for the UK startup scene. For years, founders in London and across Britain have operated under a certain set of assumptions: that the government would eventually get the 'growth' memo, that taxes on builders would stay manageable, and that being a 'tech hub' was a priority. The recent UK Budget, and the subsequent departure of high-profile advisors like Alex Depledge, suggests those assumptions were wrong.

The Departure of a Builder

Alex Depledge, a founder who has been in the trenches with Resi and Hassle.com, didn't just quit her role as an advisor to the UK government; she essentially called out the entire structural disconnect between the people making the rules and the people building the companies. When someone with that much skin in the game walks away saying there is no 'magic money tree,' builders need to stop and listen. It is a signal that the policy honeymoon is over.

The reality is that the UK government is facing a massive fiscal hole. To plug it, they are turning to the easiest targets: employers and investors. The hike in National Insurance contributions for employers and the changes to Capital Gains Tax are not just line items on a spreadsheet. For a pre-seed or Seed-stage startup, these are existential costs. If your burn rate just went up because the government needs to balance the books, your runway just got shorter.

The Lobbying Gap

One of the most striking takeaways from Depledge's exit is the realization that the startup community is terrible at lobbying. Big Tech has armies of suits in Westminster. Traditional industries like banking and manufacturing have decades of deeply entrenched relationships. Startups have a few Slack channels and the occasional Twitter thread.

We have spent too much time assuming that because we create jobs and innovation, the government will naturally want to protect us. But politics is about noise and pressure. If the startup ecosystem does not learn how to speak the language of policy—and do it with a unified voice—it will continue to be the piggy bank for every budget deficit. Builders are busy building, which is why they usually ignore politics. Depledge's experience shows that ignoring politics is becoming a luxury we can no longer afford.

Taxing the Exit

The changes to Capital Gains Tax (CGT) are perhaps the most demoralizing for the founder class. Building a company is a decade-long grind with a 90% failure rate. The only reason anyone does it is for the upside at the end of the tunnel. When the state decides to take a significantly larger bite out of that final reward, the risk-reward calculation changes.

If you are a founder in Manchester or London looking at the new tax landscape, you start wondering if it is better to incorporate in Delaware or move the operation to Lisbon or Dubai. This isn't just about 'rich people wanting to keep their money.' This is about capital flight. Capital goes where it is treated well. Right now, the UK is sending a loud message that it views successful founders as a revenue stream rather than a growth engine.

The Public Sector Fallacy

There is a recurring theme in the current government's approach: the idea that public investment can replace private dynamism. Depledge's commentary highlights the frustration of watching the government try to pick winners or create state-led 'innovation' funds while simultaneously making it harder for actual businesses to survive the next quarter.

Builders know that government money usually comes with so many strings attached that it strangles the very thing it tries to help. We don't need more government grants or 'strategy sessions.' We need a predictable tax environment and a labor market that doesn't penalize you for hiring your tenth employee.

• Increased Overhead: Higher National Insurance means every new hire is more expensive. This hits scaling startups the hardest.
• Reduced Incentive: CGT hikes dampen the 'pot of gold' motivation that drives high-risk entrepreneurship.
• Policy Blindness: A lack of founder-led representation in government leads to laws that have unintended consequences for small, fast-moving teams.

What Builders Should Do Now

If you are running a company in the UK right now, you cannot wait for a policy U-turn. You have to build for the reality on the ground. This means prioritizing profitability sooner. The 'growth at all costs' model was already dying, but this Budget just buried it. If your business model relies on cheap labor or government subsidies, you are in trouble.

We also need to rethink how we engage with the state. Founders need to stop being 'apolitical.' This doesn't mean becoming a partisan hack; it means realizing that the rules of the game are being written by people who have never had to make payroll. We need more voices like Depledge—people who aren't afraid to walk away when the advice is being ignored.

The Bottom Line

The UK is at a crossroads. It can either be a place that cultivates the next generation of global tech leaders, or it can be a cautionary tale of how to tax an ecosystem into stagnation. Depledge's departure is the canary in the coal mine. She saw that the 'magic money tree' doesn't exist, but she also saw that the government is more interested in harvesting the orchard than planting new trees.

The biggest risk to the UK right now isn't a lack of ideas; it is a lack of incentive to execute them here.

For those of us in the AI and crypto space, this is a reminder that geography still matters. Decentralization is a goal, but your tax bill is very much centralized. If the UK wants to remain a top-tier tech destination, it needs to stop treating founders like an ATM and start treating them like the primary stakeholders in the country's future.

Read the original at Sifted →