The Price of Peak Multiples
In 2021, Intuit dropped $12 billion to acquire Mailchimp. At the time, the world was awash in cheap capital, and every legacy SaaS platform was being valued as if it were a high-growth startup. Fast forward to today, and Bending Spoons has scooped up that same asset for $3.68 billion. If you are doing the math, that is a 70% haircut.
For those who do not know Bending Spoons, they are essentially the private equity version of a software surgeon. They buy apps with massive user bases—like Evernote and Meetup—trim the excess, hike the prices, and optimize for cash flow. They do not care about being the cool kid at the tech conference. They care about the bottom line.
The Intuit Miscalculation
Intuit bought Mailchimp because they wanted to own the full stack for small businesses. The idea was simple: if you use QuickBooks for your accounting, you should use Mailchimp for your marketing. Synergy is the word consultants use to justify these massive price tags. But the reality is that integrating two massive, aging codebases is harder than it looks on a slide deck.
Mailchimp was once the gold standard for email. They had the brand, the mascot, and the market share. But as the platform tried to become a "marketing hub," it lost the simplicity that made it a household name. Builders moved to nimbler alternatives like Beehiiv or Substack for newsletters, and Klaviyo for e-commerce. Intuit realized they were holding a declining asset that required too much maintenance to keep up with the new guard.
The Bending Spoons Playbook
If you are a founder, you need to watch Bending Spoons closely. They represent a shift in the software landscape from "growth at all costs" to "efficiency at any cost." When they took over Evernote, they moved the headquarters, laid off a significant portion of the staff, and restructured the pricing. It was painful for the long-time users, but it made the business sustainable.
Expect the same for Mailchimp. They are going to look at the product and ask what 20% of the features drive 80% of the value. Anything that does not make sense will be cut. This is not about innovation; it is about preservation. They are buying a reliable cash machine that Intuit no longer wanted to manage.
What This Means for AI and Crypto Builders
We are currently seeing a similar valuation bubble in the AI space. Companies with minimal revenue are raising at billion-dollar valuations because of the perceived potential. The Mailchimp saga is a sobering reminder that eventually, the bill comes due. If your business is valued at a 50x multiple during a hype cycle, you better hope you never have to sell when the market cools down.
In the crypto world, we see this with aging protocols. Projects that raised hundreds of millions in 2020 are now struggling to find product-market fit in a world that demands actual utility. If you are building today, your goal should be to build something that can survive without the venture capital drip. You want to be the one buying the discounted assets in five years, not the one being sold for pennies on the dollar.
The Consolidation Era
We are entering the era of the "SaaS Graveyard," where once-great companies are consolidated into larger holdings. For Bending Spoons, this is a massive win. They are getting an industry-standard name for a bargain price. Even at a 70% discount, Mailchimp still generates significant revenue. For Bending Spoons, it is a low-risk bet on a brand that still has name recognition.
For the rest of the industry, it is a signal that the 2021 party is officially over. The excess has been trimmed. The companies that survived the last few years are now being valued based on their EBITDA, not their dreams. This is actually a good thing for builders who are focused on real problems. It clears out the noise and leaves room for new players to disrupt the incumbents who are now focused on cost-cutting rather than building.
A Lesson in Exit Strategy
The founders of Mailchimp famously never took outside funding before the Intuit sale. They walked away with billions. Intuit is the one taking the loss here. There is a lesson there about timing. If someone offers you a life-changing amount of money based on a valuation that makes no sense, you take it. Because eventually, the market will correct itself.
Bending Spoons is betting that Mailchimp can still be a pillar of the internet's infrastructure. They might be right. But it will be a leaner, more expensive, and less experimental version of the company we used to know. For founders, the goal is simple: build something so useful that even the skeptics have to buy it, but stay lean enough that you never find yourself in a position where you have to be rescued by a company named after a utensil.
The value of a company isn't what the last VC paid for it; it is what the next buyer is willing to pay when the hype dies down.
We are seeing the market return to sanity. It is a cold, hard sanity, but it is one that builders can actually plan around. Don't chase the $12 billion ghost. Build the $3 billion reality.
Read the original at TechCrunch Startups →